Determining Fertility Index Value From Soil Test Results
Source: University of Maryland Cooperative Extension, 1996
"Interconverting Among Soil Test Analyses Frequently Used in Maryland"
Soil Fertility Management 4
Regulatory Citation: COMAR 15.20.08.05E
Anyone wanting information about taking a soil test and where to send
it for analysis, click
here.
What Do Soil Tests Measure?
Soil testing is a useful tool that can help ensure the efficient use of applied plant nutrients. Soil
tests provide a means for assessing the fertility status of a soil, but soil tests do not provide a
direct measure of the actual quantity of plant available nutrients in the soil. Instead, soil tests
measure the quantity of a nutrient element that is extractable from a soil by a particular chemical
extracting solution. The measured quantity of extractable nutrient in a soil is then used to predict
the crop yield response to application of the nutrient as fertilizer, manure, or other amendment.
As soil test levels increase for a particular nutrient, the expected crop yield response to additions
of that nutrient decreases.
Why Are There So Many Different Soil Testing Procedures?
Over the years, many different soil testing procedures and extracting solutions have been
evaluated in an effort to identify the method that provides the most reliable prediction of crop
yield response to nutrient application. It has been determined that some soil testing procedures
are best suited for particular soil types and climatic regions while other soil testing procedures are
better suited for different soil types and climates. Also, we have learned that there are often
several alternative soil testing methodologies that generate equally useful predictions of expected
crop response for a given region. There are several different soil testing procedures that work
well for Maryland soils.
Why Are There So Many Different Ways to Express Soil Test Results?
The actual numerical soil test values are products of laboratory procedures that determine the
concentrations of extractable plant nutrients in the soil. Thus, soil-test values are merely arbitrary
index numbers and not measures of the actual quantity of plant available nutrients present in a
soil. Historically in Maryland, the numerical soil test values have been converted to units of
"pounds per acre" of soil test nutrient expressed as a fertilizer equivalent (e.g. P2O5, K2O).
However, pounds per acre of the actual nutrient element (e.g. P, K), concentration of the nutrient
element in a given volume of soil (e.g. ppm, mg/dm3), or concentration of the nutrient element in
a given weight of soil (e.g. ppm) are all equally valid expressions of soil test results. The
numerical soil test values are determined by units used to express the results.
An alternative method for expressing the relative level of plant available nutrients measured by
soil testing uses "soil fertility index values". Soil fertility index values comprise a continuous
relative scale that is calculated from the concentration of extractable nutrients measured in the
laboratory, where the highest concentration within the "optimum" range is set equal to a soil
fertility index value of 100. The numerical value of the soil fertility index is not affected by
method of soil analysis or the units used to express the soil test results.
Different Tests Yield Different Results
Different soil testing laboratories use different soil testing procedures. Different soil testing
procedures generate different analytical results. Different analytical results may or may not yield
different crop nutrient application recommendations. Regardless of the soil testing methods
utilized, the analytical results generated must be correlated to crop yield responses under local
growing conditions in order to provide reliable nutrient recommendations.
Who Is In the Soil Testing Business In Maryland?
At one time, soil testing was almost exclusively performed by public (university or state agency)
laboratories. The University of Maryland Cooperative Extension Service Soil Testing Laboratory
has been providing analyses of farmers' soils since 1954. Today, many private-sector soil testing
laboratories are providing high-quality soil testing services for our agricultural community. In
general, the private-sector laboratories have excellent analytical capabilities and generate reliable
analytical results. However, direct application of the analytical results generated by different soil
testing laboratories to the crop nutrient recommendations developed by the Maryland Cooperative
Extension Service has been difficult because of the differences in the numerical values and units
used in expression of analytical results.
A recent survey of certified nutrient management consultants conducted by the Maryland
Department of Agriculture identified three major private-sector soil testing laboratories that are
frequently used by Maryland farmers: A & L Eastern Agricultural Laboratories, Inc. (Richmond,
Virginia), Brookside Laboratories, Inc. (New Knoxville, Ohio), and the Agronomic Services
Laboratory of Spectrum Analytic, Inc. (Washington Court House, Ohio).
Interconverting Among Soil Test Analyses
This publication represents the initial attempt to provide simple factors for interconverting the
analytical results generated by Maryland's three major private-sector soil testing laboratories and
the soil test values used by the Maryland Cooperative Extension Service. These conversion
factors will permit the direct application of the crop nutrient recommendations developed in
Maryland to analytical data regardless of how, where, or by whom the soil test was performed.
The conversion sequences presented in Tables 1 through 4 are intended to be simple and
easy-to-use. The conversions were empirically derived from analysis of numerous Maryland
agricultural soils by each of the participating soil testing laboratories. The conversion of
private-sector laboratory analyses will generate reliable approximations of Maryland soil test
values to which the Maryland plant nutrient recommendations may be applied.
It is very simple to convert from the old Maryland "pounds per acre" format to the new soil
fertility index values. Simply follow the conversion sequences outlined in Table 1.
Conversion sequences for interconverting between soil test data generated by A&L Eastern
Agricultural Laboratories, Inc., Brookside Laboratories, Inc. and the Agronomic Services
Laboratory of Spectrum Analytic, Inc. and University of Maryland Soil Testing Laboratory data
are given in Tables 2, 3, and 4, respectively.
Conversions Using FERTREC PLUS 2.2
Interconversion of analytical results among the three major private-sector soil testing
laboratories and Maryland's soil test values is a new feature of the University of Maryland's
FERTREC PLUS 2.2 nutrient management software program. The conversion options in
FERTREC PLUS 2.2 allow the direct application of laboratory data from any of these soil testing
laboratories in development of plant nutrient recommendations based on Maryland research and
Maryland growing conditions.
Table 1. Conversion sequences for interconverting between University of Maryland
Cooperative Extension Service Soil Testing Laboratory "pounds per acre" of soil test nutrient and
Maryland soil fertility index values.
|
To convert from "pounds per acre"
of soil test nutrient to soil fertility
index value, multiply "pounds per
acre" by the value in Col. 1 and
then add the value in Col. 2. |
Col. 1 |
Col. 2 |
To convert from soil fertility index
value to "pounds per acre" of soil test nutrient, subtract the value in Col. 2
from the soil fertility index value and then divide by the value in Col. 1. |
| P2O5, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.499 |
(-2.327) |
P fertility
index value |
|
K2O, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.314 |
(-0.439) |
K fertility index
value |
| Mg, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.382 |
0.271 |
Mg fertility index
value |
| Ca, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.058 |
0.403 |
Ca fertility index
value |
Table 2. Conversion sequences for interconverting between A & L Eastern Agricultural
Laboratories soil test data and University of Maryland Soil Testing Laboratory soil test data.
|
To convert from University of Maryland soil test data to an equivalent A & L Laboratories
value, multiply the Maryland soil test data by the value in Col. 1 and then add the value in
Col. 2. |
Col. 1 |
Col. 2 |
To convert from A & L
Laboratories soil test data to an equivalent Univ. of Maryland value, subtract the value in
Col. 2 from the A & L Laboratories soil test value and then divide by the value in Col.
1. |
| University of Maryland |
|
|
A & L
Laboratories |
| P2O5, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.333 |
10.823 |
P1 (Weak
Bray), ppm |
| K2O, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.476 |
19.195 |
K,
ppm |
| Mg, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.543 |
(-11.070) |
Mg, ppm |
| Ca, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.411 |
239 |
Ca,
ppm |
Table 3. Conversion sequences for interconverting between Brookside Laboratories soil
test data and University of Maryland Soil Testing Laboratory soil test data.
| To convert from University of Maryland soil test data to an equivalent
Brookside Laboratories value, multiply the Maryland soil test data by the value in Col. 1 and
then add the value in Col. 2. |
Col. 1 |
Col. 2 |
To convert
from Brookside Laboratories soil test data to an equivalent University of Maryland value, subtract
the value in Col. 2 from the Brookside laboratories soil test value and then divide by the value
in Col. 1. |
| University of Maryland |
|
|
Brookside
Laboratories |
| P2O5, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.445 |
9.504 |
Easily
Extractable P, ppm |
| K2O, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.648 |
9.844 |
K,
ppm |
| Mg, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.6984.208 |
Mg, ppm |
|
| Ca, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.523 |
432 |
Ca,
ppm |
Table 4. Conversion sequences for interconverting between Spectrum Analytic soil test
data and University of Maryland Soil Testing Laboratory soil test data.
| To convert from University of Maryland soil test data to an
equivalent Spectrum Analytic value, multiply the Maryland soil test data by the value in Col.
1 and then add the value in Col. 2. |
Col. 1 |
Col. 2 |
To
convert from Spectrum Analytic soil test data to an equivalent Univ. of Maryland value, subtract
the value in Col. 2 from the Spectrum Analytic soil test value and then divide by the value in
Col. 1. |
| University of Maryland |
|
|
Spectrum
Analytic |
| P2O5, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.732 |
18.414 |
P, lbs/A,
pounds
per acre |
| K2O, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
1.022 |
38.322 |
K, lbs/A,
pounds per acre |
| Mg, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
1.094 |
7.518 |
Mg, lbs/A, pounds
per acre |
| Ca, lbs/A, pounds per acre |
0.758 |
383 | Ca, lbs/A, pounds per
acre |